Demystifying Chinese Medicine – Yin and Yang

If you know anything at all about Chinese Medicine, or about the classical Chinese culture that it grew out of, it is probably the words Yin and Yang. The T’iai Chi Tu symbol, depicting the way Yin and Yang harmonise with each other, appears frequently. I even knew an accountant who had it on his business card! I guess balance is important in accounting too!

Yin and Yang are indeed key concepts in Chinese Medicine, but what do they really mean? Is it just a lot of mystical hot air?

The concepts originate in the observation that many aspects of the natural world are bipolar, they have two opposite poles. Day and night. Hot and cold. Up and down. Earth and sky. Winter and summer.  This is something so obvious it can be overlooked. Yang corresponds to daytime and therefore to warmth, light and movement. Yin is night-time, cold, dark, still. By extension, Yang is energy and consciousness, Yin is matter and substance.

In human life too the same thing is observed: inhaling and exhaling, systole and diastole, waking and sleeping, talking and being quiet, working and relaxing,  we move between opposites all of the time. The ancient Chinese, however, developed this apparently banal observation into a rather sophisticated philosophy of life which encompasses not just medicine but everything from martial arts to flower arranging.

When applied to medicine, this leads to the crucial idea, somewhat similar to the rather neglected western medical notion of homeostasis, that health involves maintaining balance. If Yin and Yang are harmonised in our body, in our mind, in our life, we are healthy people. Lose this balance for some reason, and illness results. The balance is not a static one, however; as the T’ai Chi Tu illustrates, Yin and Yang are inter-dependent, fluidly transforming into each other in the same way as day gradually gives way to night. A healthy person moves from Yin to Yang and back again in harmony with their environment.

Still, that is all a bit vague perhaps. It becomes more concrete when we start to apply it to specific aspects of the human being. For example, consider the blood. The Yang aspect of the blood is its movement; the Yin aspect is the actual substance of the blood, what it is made up of.  Clearly we need both; the blood needs to circulate and flow freely, and it needs to contain enough oxygen and other nutrients. If the Yang of the blood is lacking, we may have circulation problems such as Raynaud’s disease. If the blood is Yin deficient, we may, for instance, have anaemia.

As with the blood, so with any aspect of our being; we can speak of the Yin and Yang of the digestive system or of the kidneys; of the food that we eat and of our daily routine; of our constitution and of our temperament; of our body weight and of our body temperature. Ill health from this perspective starts to arise when, at some level of our being, we start to get out of balance. Maybe this initial disharmony begins in our emotional life or with poor eating habits; maybe it begins with an adventitious infection or with overdoing it at work. To begin with we can probably cope but, if we do not take steps to put things right, eventually our ability to self-regulate can be overwhelmed and imbalance starts to take root, and this has a knock on effect throughout our system.

To take an example, suppose we get into the habit of working late into the evening and not getting enough sleep. Maybe we use caffeine or some other stimulant to keep this up. After a few months of this we start becoming irritable and edgy, but we choose to ignore this. As well as not giving our self sufficient time to rest, we now find that the quality of the sleep we do get is not so great. Alarm bells are ringing, but we are choosing to ignore them!

As time goes by, our palms are becoming sweaty, and we have lost weight; we have a bit of a dry mouth a lot of the time, and a tickly cough. Sometimes at night we feel our heart fluttering, which finally wakes us up to the fact that we ought to get some help.

From the classical Chinese perspective, we have been giving the Yin side of our nature a bit of a hammering. When we should have been relaxed or asleep (Yin) we have been awake and active (Yang). To achieve this we have been using a Yang stimulant (caffeine) at the time of day when Yang should be taking a back seat.

So we end up without enough Yin. We are undernourished and over tired. Since Yin is related to stillness and calm, we are edgy and nervous. Sweaty palms, insomnia, weight loss, a dry mouth and a tickly cough are all classic signs of Yin deficiency, as are heart palpitations that happen in the evening. A practitioner of Chinese medicine will probably consider that the Yin deficiency relates especially to the kidneys, lungs and heart.

To restore health we clearly need to make some changes to our lifestyle; in particular we need to nourish the Yin by giving ourselves time to rest, perhaps by learning (again) to simply be for a bit, without so much doing (if we have been overworking because we need the money, this may be challenging, but not as challenging as what will be happening further on down the road if we don’t take ourselves in hand!). We may also need some treatment to help us; in Traditional Chinese Medicine this may be some acupuncture to calm the mind and nourish the Yin of the heart, kidneys and lungs, maybe also some herbal Yin tonics, and some advice on foods we can eat to nourish the Yin. Qigong or meditation are also a good idea.

Now the human being is a complex thing, and most health problems are not a straightforward case of Yin deficiency or Yang deficiency – or of Yin or Yang excess for that matter. Often the picture is complex and it takes some skill to fathom the ways in which Yin and Yang are out of kilter. There may, for instance, be Yin deficiency in one part of our system and Yang deficiency in another part. It becomes more complex still when we consider that one of the principal characteristics of Yin and Yang is that they transform into each other, as the day passes into night and an arthritic finger joint becomes hot and painfully inflamed if exposed to cold weather.

The human being is an incredibly complex system of inter-relationships and balances, and a big part of the art of healing is for the clinician to perceive just where the fundamental disharmony lies, so that when this is rectified by the appropriate treatment everything else falls into place and we start feeling ourselves again. One of the characteristics of this traditional Chinese medical approach is thus that it looks to treat the disharmony at the root of our problem, rather than just giving symptomatic relief which is not likely to successful in the long run; either our symptoms will return, or new ones will take their place.

There Is Much More to Pain Relief Than Painkillers

For many people, pain relief means painkillers. However, there are many more ways of obtaining pain relief, which is just as well, especially for those who suffer with chronic pain. After all, painkillers don’t always work, and they also have a number of unfortunate side effects. Opioid painkillers such as tramadol for instance, tend to inhibit deep REM sleep, the kind of sleep which is important for health in general and for managing pain in particular. NSAIDs like ibuprofen and dicolfenac taken long term are associated with a higher risk of heart disease and stroke, as well as potentially life-threatening gastro-intestinal complications, and there is also some research which suggests they slow down healing (which is not surprising if you remember that the inflammation that such drugs are inhibiting is part of the body’s natural healing process). Painkillers can also sometimes actually cause pain, as was made clear earlier this year in the new NICE guidelines for the treatment of headache. So, for reasons like these, we need to remember that there is lot more to pain relief than drugs. Anyone suffering from chronic pain, in particular, needs more than one string to their pain relieving bow.

Broadly speaking there are two different kinds of pain relief. The first kind blocks or kills the pain without doing anything to help the problem which is causing the pain; this is how painkillers work. We might call this symptomatic pain relief. Such an approach may be sufficient in the case of a minor injury which can be expected to resolve itself (although bear in mind the point made previously about NSAIDs slowing down healing.) In most cases, however, and especially in the case of chronic pain, symptomatic pain relief is no substitute for getting to the root of the problem, which is what the second type of pain relief aims to do, what we might call true pain relief. This kind of treatment aims to promote the body’s own healing responses and to resolve underlying disharmonies and tensions, so that the cause of the pain is removed, or at least attenuated.

Pain in essence is an alarm signal telling us that there is some damage to part of our body which needs attending to; maybe it simply needs protecting for a while, or maybe it needs some form of treatment. Getting into the habit of simply using painkillers to block the alarm signal is therefore a bad idea, a little like shutting down the fire alarm without finding out if there is a fire.

If we are not going to rely exclusively on painkillers for pain relief, what other options are there? Quite a few, as detailed below; some require a qualified clinician, others can be self-administered. Not all of these are suitable for everyone; it is a matter of putting together an individualised package of measures, perhaps with the help of a clinician, to create a personalised pain relief plan.

i) Acupuncture

Acupuncture has been used in China and other parts of the Far East for literally millennia in the treatment of pain, and is now used extensively for that purpose all over the world, including by many conventional medical practitioners. These latter tend to use acupuncture primarily as a symptomatic painkiller without significant side effects; we might feel a bit ‘woozy’ after an acupuncture treatment, or maybe get a little bruise, but that is likely to be the sum of things side effects-wise. From this conventional point of view, acupuncture works by stimulating the release of the body’s own internal painkilling substances, such as endorphins, as well as by activating certain kinds of peripheral nerve endings which block the signals sent by pain detecting nerves at the spinal cord, so that the pain signals do not reach the brain. Acupuncture is also used by some conventional medical practitioners to treat pain caused by tight muscles; in this case treatment goes beyond symptomatic pain relief because it releases the trigger point in the muscle which is the cause of the pain (although we also need to be asking why the muscle was tight in the first place.)

Traditional Chinese acupuncture, on the other hand, focuses more on true pain relief, since it looks to find the source of the pain and resolve that. In Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) pain is essentially a blockage in the free flow of something called Qi; a traditional Chinese medical saying has it that “where there is no flow, there is pain.” Our clinician aims, through careful questioning and examination, to understand why the flow of the Qi is blocked. This may be a purely local blockage, or it may involve a more systemic imbalance. Acupuncture treatment then frees up the flow of the Qi and works to resolve the underlying disharmonies which are at the root of the blockage. This is a holistic approach to pain relief.

ii) Relaxation

In Traditional Chinese Medicine there is a saying that ‘all pain comes from the heart’. Whilst this might look like a bit of an exaggeration, it corresponds to what conventional medicine refers to as the affective component of pain. Pain is a very complex thing. If the weather is miserable and we have just lost our job, any physical pain will probably feel worse. If the sun is shining and someone smiles at us, it may not feel so bad. Basically, our mood has a significant effect on pain, whatever the primary cause of the pain. This is the affective component of pain – ‘affective’ means influenced by or resulting from the emotions. This means in turn that doing things which help raise our mood, in particular which help us to feel more relaxed, calmer, more at peace with ourselves, can be important in pain relief.

Finding ways that work for us, ways to help us to develop calmness, peacefulness, mindfulness, are in fact very important. Pain itself can be a cause of stress – we worry about how we are going to cope, whether the pain will ever go, whether we will be able to get any sleep. Pain can get us down in an overwhelming kind of way. This leads us into what is called the pain cycle: pain creates stress, which makes the pain worse, which makes us more stressed….a truly vicious circle. Learning some simple meditation techniques or perhaps practising something like T’ai Chi or Chi Kung if that is appropriate for our condition, or maybe using some good relaxation CDs can be a vital part of our learning to break the pain cycle.

Of course, if we are in a lot of pain it may be very difficult for us to begin to relax – our instinctive response may be to tighten up to protect ourselves. In this case, we will probably need some skilled help, from a Chi Kung or meditation teacher for instance.

iii) Appropriate Exercise and Rest.

It is important to rest up for a day or two after an acute injury, so that the body can start healing itself. After that initial rest, and certainly in the case of most chronic pain conditions, exercise is crucial in promoting healing and pain relief.

Sometimes specific exercises are appropriate for a given condition, and expert advice will probably be necessary from your clinician. For instance, many cases of sciatic-type pain are caused by tightness in the muscles of the buttock, particularly the piriformis muscle. Treatments such as acupuncture and deep massage can help release this tightness, but we can help ourselves by doing exercises to relax these muscles. (Although we also need to understand why the muscles are tight in the first place and take steps to stop them tightening up again).

More generally, even light exercise such as walking is often helpful in giving pain relief. Or if our pain is exacerbated by walking, as may be case with arthritis of the knee, for instance, swimming might be a better option. From the point of view of traditional Chinese Medicine, something as simple as brisk walking promotes the flow of Qi. Since pain is ultimately Qi which is not flowing, this will help. In conventional terms, exercise increases endorphin levels; endorphins are the body’s own painkillers. By the way, laughter also increases endorphin release, and in Chinese medicine terms it releases blocked Qi, which explains the pain control regime of the American journalist Norman Cousins for whom watching Marx brothers’ movies, and having a good belly laugh, formed an important part of a pain relief programme.

So in most cases, some gentle exercise is going to contribute to pain relief, but we will need to get advice from our clinician about what is right for us. Too much of the wrong kind of exercise is going to make things worse, of course. Remember that if we overdo it we are making it more difficult for the body to heal itself. Expert advice is important, but it is also worth learning to ‘listen’ to our body. If our body needs rest, or if it needs to move, it will let us know if we pay attention. Some of us are liable to reinjure ourselves by overdoing things too quickly; others of us are more likely to be too inactive and slow down the healing process; we need to know ourselves!

iv) Sleep

Sleep is often a big issue for people in pain, especially for those who are kept awake, or woken up, by their pain. Such sleep disturbance adds insult to injury, because sleep is crucial in any healing process. In particular deep REM sleep is important in tissue recovery. Therefore, if we can, we need to make sure we can get sufficient sleep, or at least as much as possible. There is some evidence that modern lifestyles are leading to people to miss out on sleep; burning the candle at both ends is not a good idea if we are someone who is in pain. Sometimes, with certain kinds of musculoskeletal pain for instance, it may be a matter of finding a position in which we can be more or less pain free; for instance, with some kinds of low back pain, sleeping on our side with a pillow or cushion between our knees may ease any discomfort.

v) Hot and Cold

One of the questions a traditional acupuncturist will always ask us about a painful condition is how it responds to temperature changes. Does it get worse in cold weather? Is it better if we hold a hot water bottle against the area in question? If the answer to these questions is ‘yes’, then straight away we have a useful pain reducing treatment available – warmth. And we also know that we should avoid exposing the area to the cold. If on the other hand, the painful area feels hot and looks red, heat may not be such a good idea (although sometimes there might be exceptions to this, where we can fight fire with fire.) In TCM, acupuncture treatment is often accompanied by the use of moxibustion, the burning of the herb mugwort to warm acupuncture points and key areas of the body.

In the west, it is common to use ice to kill pain, especially in the case of inflammation. TCM is not hot on ice (pun intended!); one traditional Chinese doctor/martial artist is reported as saying that ‘ice is for dead people’. TCM uses other forms of treatment for inflammation, such as cupping and acupuncture. This is because whilst the ice may stop the pain in the short term, it can impair the flow of Qi through the area in the long run. If we do use ice, therefore, it is best to use it for short bursts, say 15 minutes at a time. Or we can alternate between ice and warmth.

vi) Food

Eating well is an important aspect of any pain management programme; and for a number of reasons. To begin with, being overweight is a big contributory factor to a number of painful conditions. For instance, if we have chronic knee or low back pain, any extra weight we are carrying increases the load on the knee or spinal joints. Losing weight is not always an easy matter, and we may need some kind of therapeutic assistance, but if we are carrying more weight than our body is ‘designed’ for, it is not surprising that we are suffering.

However, there is more to the connection between food and pain than that. TCM has a sophisticated understanding of how different foods and indeed different ways of cooking (and eating!) food impact upon our systems. For instance, if we have painful joints which are swollen and puffy, and which maybe feel worse in damp weather conditions, there are certain foodstuffs, including dairy and wheat products, which will reinforce the tendency to fluid congestion and make such pain worse – and there are certain other foods which can play a part in relieving that congestion. Thus a well-trained TCM clinician will be able to make personalised suggestions as to ways we can use food as part of a pain relief regime. This is very much a matter of finding a diet for ourselves which restores our natural balance and harmony.

Conventional medicine is also waking up to the way that diet impacts upon pain levels; in particular it is discovering how a poor diet lacking in fruit and vegetables and including too much sugar and processed foods promotes inflammation; which is to say that the body responds to such food as if it were a pathogen!

vii) TENS

TENS stands for transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation. It involves running a small electrical current between adhesive electrodes strategically placed at points on the skin related to the location of our pain. A pleasant tingling sensation is felt in the process. TENS machines can be purchased from major chemists and are quite safe providing we follow the manufacturer’s instructions. TENS works by blocking pain signals from the source of the pain as they enter the spinal cord, in something called the gate control theory of pain control. Basically it shuts the door, or closes the gate, on the pain message so that it does not reach the brain, and we therefore feel no pain. Like painkillers, therefore, TENS is a form of treatment that blocks pain but does nothing to address the cause of the pain, but it can be a useful method of combating pain whilst the cause is dealt with either by other forms of treatment or by the body’s own healing process.

The important thing with TENS is to position the electrodes appropriately so that they block pain signals from the right area. Our clinicians are be able to advise if necessary. There are a number of situations in which TENS should not be used, for example in the first trimester of pregnancy and if the patient has a pacemaker; click here for more details.

viii) Massage

Massage is obviously particularly useful in the treatment of pain which has its origin in tight and knotted muscles and related tissue pathology. However, even when the initial origin of the pain is not muscular, muscle tightness may arise secondary to the problem and contribute significantly to the pain we feel. For instance, if we have osteoarthritis of the hip, it is likely that our buttock muscles will become tight and tense because of this, and sometimes this muscle tightness may cause much of the pain we feel, a fact that can be overlooked. On top of that, as mentioned before pain is inherently stressful, and stress leads us to tighten up in the shoulders and neck, in the abdomen, in many places; so a relaxing massage will nearly always be helpful in pain management.

There is a lot to be said, in fact, for the healing power of touch. We might remember our mother ‘rubbing it better’ when we fell over as a child. A physical exam by a trained clinician, even before they start using acupuncture or massage or whatever they are going to do, can be the start of the healing process. When we are in pain, of course, we need to be listened to properly by our clinician; we need to feel they understand something of what it is like for us. Maybe also we need their touch as part of this process. Our patients often comment that conventional medicine sometimes seems to marginalise this vital aspect of healing; how often does a GP put his or her hands on our lower back if we go to them complaining of low back pain? X-rays and Ultrasound scans are wonderful things, but it is a shame if they end up completely taking the place of diagnosis by touch.

Of course massage needs to be appropriate for the painful condition we have; like all forms of treatment it needs to be tailored to the individual. One person may need vigorous deep massage, another only the gentlest of touches.

ix) Cupping

Cupping is a traditional medical technique used in many different cultures across the world. It involves lowering the pressure inside a glass or plastic ‘cup’, either by using a naked flame or a simple suction device, and placing the cup on the skin. In TCM, cupping is often used alongside acupuncture to remove obstructions to the free flow of Qi, for instance on the knees or hips. The expansion of tissue under the skin where the cups are placed causes increased blood flow and drains toxins and stagnant blood, as well as stretching and releasing any rigid soft tissue. Sometimes the cups are simply left in place for several minutes, or sometimes, when used on the back for instance, they may be slid up and down to further invigorate the flow of Qi.

x) Posture and Ergonomics

Some kinds of pain can be caused, or made worse; by the way we hold and move ourselves. Repetitive strain injury, for instance, arises when damage builds up in muscles, tendons and other structures due to continued and repetitive movements such as our bodies were not evolved for. Clearly we can help alleviate such pain by either ceasing from the activity altogether, or if that is not possible, modifying the way we do it or undertaking some compensatory exercise or self-massage. For instance, using a computer mouse for several hours at a time is not something our hands, wrists, arms and shoulders were evolved to do. This can lead to tissue damage and pain. We can, however, train ourselves to use the mouse with our other hand some of the time, or perhaps invest in an ergonomic mouse. (Ergonomics is the study of the ‘fit’ between people and their work environments and involves adapting the work environment so that it does not cause problems for the worker’s health).We can take breaks from using the mouse and use the opportunity to loosen up our shoulder and elbow and maybe do some light massage on our wrist and forearm.

In general terms, we can make changes to how we position and use our body at work and at home (how do we stand when we are doing the washing up? How do we sit down to watch the telly? Ergonomics is not just about work!) so that we are not continually re-injuring ourselves, and so our body has a good chance to heal itself. We can help ourselves by bringing awareness to how we are holding, positioning and moving ourselves; indeed in some cases the pain we feel may be our body letting us know that we are habitually mistreating it. Although it might sound churlish to talk about something as unpleasant as pain having advantages, nevertheless it is true that some individuals with chronic pain problems become much more self-aware, in a number of ways, than they used to be.

xi) Topical Applications

A very traditional form of pain relief, of course, relies on creams and liniments which can be rubbed onto the affected area. Conventional applications use painkilling drugs such as NSAIDs, which are subject to some of the reservations mentioned above; in TCM, herbal applications such as Tiger Balm are used. Red Tiger Balm is made up of ingredients like camphor and menthol and mint oil; White Tiger Balm has more mint oil and is used where there is heat and inflammation.

Conclusion

Anyone in pain for more than a day or two, and particularly those with chronic pain conditions, need a pain relief programme incorporating some of the above, either in addition to or in place of painkillers. Working out such a programme with a qualified clinician is probably the best approach, as they will have expert advice on a number of methods such as exercise and diet.

Illness and Responsibility

Why do we get ill? No doubt the answer is often complex, and it is a mistake to think there is just one single cause when very often it is a combination of factors. In Traditional Chinese Medicine these factors include inherited imbalances, poor dietary choices, climatic factors, lifestyle issues and, not least, emotional difficulties. Most of these things we can influence, for better or for worse. This then raises what may be a controversial question. If we are ill, is it our fault? On the one hand, if we tend to answer yes to this question – maybe we eat badly, or avoid exercise, or keep ourselves trapped in a long-standing state of anger or anxiety – this can lead to guilt and even self-loathing, which will only make matters worse. On the other hand, if we bristle with resentment at the very suggestion that our suffering may, in part, be our own doing, we can settle down into the role of the helpless victim.

Thus, especially if we have a serious and chronic illness such as ME or cancer, we need to work out our emotional response to the question, “Why me?” This response needs to avoid the extremes of, on the one hand, beating ourselves up about it all and, on the other, of taking up the role of helpless and resentful victim. In fact this is an issue which every human being has to face, as every one of us reaps the consequences of how we have lived, and few of us have lived like an angel or a sage. Most of us have made mistakes, and have to live with the consequences of those mistakes, whether those consequences manifest as illness or in some other way.

So what should our attitude be to the past? Perhaps we need to acknowledge it, and, in the context of illness, acknowledge the ways in which we may have contributed to our getting ill. However, we may instead say that we have not the faintest idea why we are ill. This is especially so when our health system is so technical and specialised. How can we, a mere layman, understand why we have the illness we have? Something is going wrong, and we do not understand it, and do not understand why it is happening. This may tend to put is in the victim camp.

On the other hand, perhaps we can free ourselves from the shackles of technical medicine, and use our intuition. The more self-awareness we have, the more likely our intuition, or even our common sense, will tell us why we are the way we are. If I go around all the time in a constant state of fear, with my shoulders hunched up, is it not possible that I may end up with a headache or an arthritic neck? If I am always angry and frustrated, is it not possible that my blood pressure gets too high? If I always gobble down my food whilst doing something else, not chewing it properly, is it not possible that I will get some kind of digestive problem, like a stomach ulcer or acid reflux? In some ways the illness we get may be giving us some kind of feedback as to how we have lived our life to date, and if we endeavour to be receptive to that feedback, we may learn something crucial about ourselves.

Traditional Chinese Medicine is often very helpful in helping us to understand why we are ill in the way we are. For instance, it makes useful connections between different emotional states and the way they affect the individual. For example, it says that anger makes Qi rise. (Qi cannot be easily translated, but means something like ‘vital energy’) This means that anger often causes symptoms in the upper body, especially the head and neck – think migraines, headaches, tinnitus etc. Of course everyone gets angry from time to time, but problems arise when we become habitually angry, or when we repress or deny our anger. Prolonged sadness, on the other hand, depletes the Qi, and may especially affect the lungs, leading to shortness of breath, fatigue, a weak voice, even asthma.

Of course these kind of ideas need not to be applied too literally, but they give us a clue, give us a framework to ponder on the connections between our emotional lives and our illnesses. Perhaps they can stimulate us to become more sensitive to the way that emotions manifest in our body – if we are really aware, we can begin to feel how, for instance, excessive worrying is tying our Qi in knots.

If this kind of process leads us to acknowledge that our illness may in part be due to how we have lived, then , knowing that we cannot change the past, we can come back to the present, where we do have a choice. That choice may not include the option of freeing ourselves totally from the consequences of our past actions, but it does include the choice to live in such a way as can at least mitigate the effects of the illness, at least to some extent.

TREATING PEOPLE, NOT DISEASES

Diseases are not isolated discrete entities. There is not something called asthma, or sinusitis, or migraine, distinct from the person suffering from it. A disease isn’t a thing inside you in a little box, separated from the rest of you. It might work that way with something as relatively unsophisticated as a car; maybe if there is something wrong with the gearbox, it does not affect all the other systems (although maybe a mechanic might think otherwise.) But a human being is much, much more complex. Another difference of course is that a human being is alive.

What this means is that medical treatment and health care needs to take cognisance of the person as a whole, and not just focus on the disease. This also has repercussions for medical research: suppose you read that research shows that statin anti-cholesterol medication reduces the risk of death from cardiovascular disease in women who take these drugs: if you are a woman, you might then conclude that you should take statins. However, it seems that such women do not in fact live any longer; they just die of something else. (See Dr. Malcolm Kendrick’s provocative book, “The Great Cholesterol Con”). The question we need to ask of any treatment is not, “does it cure the condition?”, but, “will I be healthier?”.

A simplified model of how a human being works involves thinking of them in terms of a number of systems; the respiratory system, the digestive system, the nervous system, and so on. This is no doubt an over-simplification, but even so it does not take much thought to realise that all these systems are dynamic and inter-related, so that a small change in one of these systems has knock on effects in all the others. For instance, if your digestive system gets upset, maybe through eating some dodgy take-away, this has a knock on effect on all the others because they all rely for essential nourishment on the digestive system processing what you eat. For medical treatment to be really effective, therefore, it needs to take stock of the whole person and not just focus down on one system, or even on one sub-system, as if that system existed in isolation from all the others. It doesn’t.

To understand this, consider the case of Fred. Fred grows up as a fairly healthy child, albeit with a tendency, inherited from his dad, to be a bit on the chubby side. He does well at school and goes to university to study computer science. He enjoys his subject and happily spends long hours studying away; to unwind he goes for a few (or sometimes more than a few) beers with his mates. Already he is developing something of a beer belly, which is perhaps not helped by his reliance on fast food and take-aways. Still, he does not have any major health problems and rarely if ever sees his GP, although he notices that his stools are tending to get loose and, I’m afraid to say, rather smelly.

At this point Fred is beginning to suffer from what in Traditional Chinese Medicine we call ‘Pi Qi Xu’, which basically means a weakness of the main digestive organ, the ‘Pi’. This is weakened by a poor diet, but also by excessive intellectual work (think about the way we link intellectual activity with digestion, as in phrases such as ‘food for thought’, ‘chewing it over’, and ‘digesting information’). Intellectual indigestion causes actual indigestion. A likely consequence of this disharmony is what we call ‘damp accumulation’, an over-retention of moisture in the body, manifesting, for instance, as weight gain around the abdomen, and loose smelly stools, possibly with mucus in them (charming, I know.).

Ten years down the line, Fred has a good job in IT, which unfortunately is fairly desk-bound. He is more over-weight, still fond of a few beers, and the less said about his toileting the better. But he is also struggling a bit now. Never a morning person, he now wakes with difficulty from heavy sleep and is reliant on strong coffee to get him going. Even then he is prone to lethargy and when he gets home from work he tends to slump in front of the telly a lot. He knows he should get some exercise, but the trouble is that his knees ache and are a bit swollen, and any way he hasn’t got the motivation. In Traditional Chinese Medicine this is all more dampness, which typically produces feelings of heaviness, muzziness, dullness and apathy, like being bogged down. Fred’s long-suffering girlfriend knows that something is not right (and if truth be told is not overjoyed by the lack of bedroom action these days, and the snoring), and eventually prevails on him to see the GP. The GP thinks Fred is depressed and prescribes a low-dose antidepressant.

Ten years later Fred is still taking the anti-depressant, which did at least seem to lift his mood for a while, although the effect has worn off and his GP is reluctant to increase the dose. He is snoring badly now and may have sleep apnoea. He also seems to catch colds a lot, and his sinuses are almost constantly blocked with thick mucus which is often yellow. He is also a bit wheezy if he has to walk up a flight of stairs. The dampness has led to phlegm in the lungs and sinuses. This leads to Fred having a lot of dull headaches. Although, as you may have gathered, Fred is quite good at just putting up with less than optimal health, these headaches combined with the sinus problem have really started to get to him. He tries over-the-counter decongestant medication, he goes to his GP to get some better decongestant medication, he tries using olbas oil, but nothing seems to work for very long.

However, for as long as Fred, or the people treating him, just focus on his sinus problem, nothing much is going to happen. Whether you call this disease sinusitis or not, it has not come into existence on its own, but is simply what is, for Fred, the most obvious manifestation of something which has been going on throughout his entire being for at least 20 years. Even if he finds some slick new decongestant pill that does unblock his nose, this is just suppressing a symptom rather than healing a person, and there will no doubt be some side effects from the pill which might even mean he needs another pill. (Possible side effects of one of the most common decongestants include insomnia – which will at least put a stop to the snoring – anxiety, restlessness and a fast pulse). Fred does not need treatment for sinusitis, he needs treatment for his whole being, body and soul.

Hopefully this makes clear why we say treat the person, not the disease. We sometimes talk about treatment principles, which are the goals of treatment. If we think of treating the disease, there is only one treatment principle:

• Clear the sinuses

If, however, we think of treating Fred, the person, there are many treatment principles, some of which might be:

• Clear the sinuses
• Strengthen the digestive system (the ‘Pi Qi’)
• Drain excess moisture from the body (‘drain dampness’)
• Strengthen the respiratory system
• Work with Fred to help him develop the motivation to do more exercise
• Treat the joint pain
• Help Fred develop the motivation, and the understanding, to modify his diet to avoid clogging up his system
• Help Fred to start to consider that he might benefit from cutting down on the beer

The point is that, to really clear the sinuses and keep them clear, we need to apply all of these treatment principles. This is, of course, not the work of a day, and it is undoubtedly easier in the short term to just pop a decongestant pill. It is easier for Fred, who does not have to consider changing his life much. The trouble is that, at best, this approach frees up Fred’s sinuses for a bit, without doing anything to help with his other problems. In the long run it may see him taking several pharmaceuticals – pain-killers for his knees for instance – none of which are addressing the fundamental problems.

But, if Fred gets some kind of treatment which addresses all the principles listed above, by which is meant he gets some form of holistic treatment, and if he is able to work with whoever provides this treatment, he could end up having a life which is a whole lot better than the one he is having. So that is why it is important to treat the person and not the disease.

THE MOST IMPORTANT THING

Given the amount of time and money spent on education, not to mention the amount of time politicians spend talking about it, isn’t it surprising that many people have never learnt the most important thing in life – how to work with their mental states. So many of the people we see at the Sean Barkes Clinic are suffering either directly or indirectly from their mental states; of course many people come for help with conditions such as anxiety, panic attacks, depression, but also many of the people who present with things like headaches or digestive disturbances do so, at least in part, because of an underlying mental or emotional disharmony. Most of these people have never learned how to work with their mental states; how, for example, to transform anxiety into calmness, resentment into love, gloom into joy, greed into contentment etc. If we are unable to recognise these states, and the need to work on them, and if we don’t know how to do that, we simply end up as the passive victims of our own minds, and it will make us ill. Funny, then, that we are not taught this as a matter of course – I’m talking about things like meditation, Qi Gong, yoga, philosophical exercises, even perhaps certain forms of prayer.

Maybe it’s because it’s not easy. Anyone who tries will know that, for instance, changing an attitude of long-standing resentment or anger is a very tough thing to do. Sometimes it might be a life’s work. But given that the choice is between trying to change it, and just passively suffering its consequences, which in Chinese Medical terms will probably be an impairment of the Liver’s ability to maintain the smooth flow of Qi throughout the body and mind, leading to anything from heartburn to migraines to a stroke, we need to at least try. But to do that we need to know how to try, we need some training in a discipline such as Qi Gong, meditation or similar. Just as there are exercises to strengthen a weak back, there are things we can learn which can liberate us from restrictive and illness causing negative mental states.

By the way, I’m not implying that all illness is due to our mental states. But mental states are a factor, either in causing illness, or in how we deal with it. And mental states are things we can effect, perhaps more than we realise.